Sontag rejects the notion that war imagery will necessarily compel. The author, susan sontag, uses this tragic record of events to explore the power of imagery to tell a story that words cannot bring to light. The western memory museum is now mostly a visual one. These pictures, taken by american soldiers, on the surface tell a story of torture of those that. Cinemas 100 years seem to have the shape of a life cycle. Aktuell susan sontag regarding the torture of others for a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how. May 23, 2004 susan sontag essay offers her reflections on torture of iraqi prisoners by americans at abu ghraib, and the photographs that have appeared of that torture. Supplemented by private papers, as well as interviews with annie leibovitz, rieff, and others close to sontag whove been reluctant to share details in the past, the amount of information in sontag borders on the sensational. Jan 07, 2003 a brilliant expansion and revision of on photography, regarding the pain of others argues for approaching images of suffering only as invitations to consider the origins and impact of social inequality. When she says, no we should be taken for granted when the subject is looking at other peoples pain, i thought of how differently a patients suffering might be written about by a doctor, a nurse, a. Public intellectual and controversial essayist susan sontag published her last essay, regarding the torture of others, in the may 23, 2004, edition of the new york times magazine. Regarding the torture of others summary remy lundy mrs. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. Regarding the pain of others susan sontag macmillan.
It was her last published book before her death in 2004. Throughout her career, she had shown the dangers of separating things from their proper names. Presents susan sontag s regarding the pain of others. Adapted from an essay originally published in 2005 by publications of the modern language.
Vernon foley 2012 the author, susan sontag, uses this tragic record of events to explore the power of imagery to tell a story that words cannot bring to light. Feb 03, 2014 the voynich code the worlds most mysterious manuscript the secrets of nature duration. Thinking with sontag, butler further considers images through the work of susan sontag. Regarding the pain of others, by susan sontag garage. Regarding the pain of others 2003 was susan sontag s last published book before her death in 2004. Sontag regarding the torture of others european medi. Drawing attention to how photography is always both art and testimony, sontag convincingly deconstructs the idea that a photo of pain by itself. Wright wrt 105 6 september 2009 regarding the torture of others summary regarding the torture of others, a powerful piece written by susan sontag, focuses on the horrific pictures taken by american soldiers in the abu ghraib prison. This is susan sontags second book on photography and, like the first, published in 1977, it contains no photographs. Regarding the pain of others in susan sontag and alfredo jaar.
Susan sontag regarding the pain of others by a lau on prezi. Twentyfive years after her classic on photography, susan sontag returns to the subject of visual representations of war and violence in our culture today. The definition comes from the 1984 convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Sontag debunks a certain number of commonplaces including some that she herself endorsed on earlier occasions concerning images of war and atrocity, underscoring the importance of these images but also undercutting hopes that they can.
While relatively short, it ranges nimbly across a breadth of. Susan sontag regarding the torture of others free essays. Regarding the torture of others summary suzanne churchill. She contends that war imagery is open to both interpretation and manipulation. Because ive always thought of susan sontag as someone who uses language with precision, i found her reference to the atrocities committed by.
Now a standalone volume, this essay extends the work sontag began in on photography,examining the role that imagesparticularly violent onesplay in shaping our minds and actions. Regarding the pain of others article in visual communication quarterly 121. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Regarding the pain of others is susan sontag s searing analysis of our numbed response to images of horror. It is a followup to her classic collection of essays on photography, published 26 years earlier and recently released in russian as part of the garage publishing program in collaboration with ad marginem press. This prezi is a visual companion to susan sontag s essay, regarding the pain of others. Regarding the pain of others susan sontag chapters 8, 9. And so sontag went to work on what became her final published essay, regarding the torture of others. Sontag evaluates the use of images and the role of photography in representing how the interpretation of images.
Editions of regarding the pain of others by susan sontag. This second volume in library of americas definitive edition of her collected essays gathers under the sign of saturn 1980, aids and its metaphors 1989, where the stress falls 2001, regarding the pain of others 2003, and at the same time 2007, brilliant books in which sontag did not merely comment on the cultural and political. Regarding the pain of others photographs we feel the same things. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york. In the following chapter, torture and the ethics of photography. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Regarding the pain of others susan sontag download.
Sontag s statements about photographs of suffering might also help us think about the function of writing and reading about others suffering. She spent in sarajevo much of the time between early 1993 and 1996 and was made an honorary citizen of the city. But those certainly are dead children, and that undoubtedly is the section of a house. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 117 pages and is available in paperback format. Free download or read online regarding the pain of others pdf epub book. Her new book is a profound rethinking of the intersection of news art, and understanding in the contemporary depiction of war and disaster. Most importantly, sontag is the queerest book about one of the 20th centurys most important writers. Regarding the pain of others is a work that seeks to retrace, in sontags traditionally elliptical form, the ways in which we viewand have viewedpeoples suffering through images. In her followup to regarding the pain of others, susan sontag returns one year later with the article regarding the torture of others. Regarding the pain of others by susan sontag pdf free.
Regarding the torture of others for a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts are judged and remembered. Regarding the pain of others, by susan sontag in regarding the pain of others, susan sontag asks the reader to think about how our engagement with a photograph affects our understanding of suffering and war. Regarding the pain of others quotes by susan sontag. Can there be any real justification for the creation, and consumption, of such images. A brilliant, melancholy meditation on war photography. She argues that photographs determine how important conflicts are judged and remembered. But such films not only have to be exceptions thats true of great achievements in any art. Start your 48hour free trial to unlock this regarding the pain of others study guide and get instant access to the following summary. Again, slightlyyyyy longer than one minute but it was a really interesting. This mornings collection contains the photograph of what might be a mans body, or a womans.
She takes a strong position on defending the prisoners and uses powerful words to back her. Mar 23, 2003 regarding the pain of others by susan sontag. Drawing attention to how photography is always both art and testimony, sontag convincingly deconstructs the idea that a photo of pain by itself can reveal anything. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york times magazine. Susan sontag, regarding the pain of others new york. Sontag, regarding the torture of others the new york times. Regarding the torture of others article in ny times by susan sontag, may 23 2004 link 7 this article refers to the photographs taken in abu ghraib prison in iraq originally sadam husseins most infamous prison. Regarding the pain of others essays are academic essays for citation.
Regarding the pain of others by susan sontag, first. Sontag, regarding the torture of others the new york. Aug 21, 2018 8212018 regarding the torture of others the new york times 111 regarding the torture of others by susan sontag i. In fact, there are many uses of the innumerable opportunities that a modern life supplies for regarding at a distance, through the medium of photography other peoples pain. Regarding the pain of others by susan sontag alibris.
Regarding the torture of others colin caygill digital. Though her subject is photography, the essay is about much more than cameras. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag summary. A summary of regarding the torture of others seize the future. Regarding the pain of others kindle edition by sontag, susan. It is regarded by many to be a followup or addendum to on photography, despite the fact that the two essay collections convey sontag s radically. Regarding the torture of others the new york times. But when sontag s article came out, i wanted to see how she applied her method of inquiry and analysis to the news of american soldiers torturing whomever detainees, prisoners of war, wtfever it is they have in those iraqi prisons. A coruscating sermon on how we picture suffering the new york times what is the purpose of images of pain and suffering.
Susan sontag publishes last essay jewish womens archive. Its not that you cant look forward anymore to new films that you can admire. A summary of regarding the torture of others seize the. Sep 11, 2015 in regarding the pain of others, susan sontag takes a fresh look at the representation of atrocityfrom goyas the disasters of war to photographs of the american civil war, lynchings of blacks in the south, and the nazi death camps, to contemporary horrific images of bosnia, sierra leone, rwanda, israel and palestine, and new york city on. It is regarded by many to be a followup or addendum to on photography, despite the fact that the two essay collections convey sontag s radically different opinions about photography. This prezi is a visual companion to susan sontags essay, regarding the pain of others. Aug 02, 2003 regarding the pain of others by susan sontag hamish hamilton. Sontag is critical of the bush administration for their desire to limit a publicrelations disaster rather than deal with the complex crimes of. In regarding the pain of others, susan sontag examines the manner in which war is perceived, taking into account such factors as sex, culture and status. The main characters of this non fiction, philosophy story are. This 33page guide for regarding the pain of others by susan sontag includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 9 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. What i cant understand is how a man who calls himself a patriot in service of his country gets from his oath of service to an act like this, under the ostensibly. In regarding the pain of others, susan sontag takes a fresh look at the representation of atrocityfrom goyas the disasters of war to photographs of the american civil war, lynchings of blacks in the south, and the nazi death camps, to contemporary horrific images of bosnia, sierra leone, rwanda, israel and palestine, and new york city on. Regarding the pain of others is a 2003 booklength essay by susan sontag, which was nominated for the national book critics circle award.
Regarding the pain of others 2003, are the objects through which she. Susan sontag regarding the torture of others for a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts are judged and remembered. A quick summary of regarding the torture of others by susan sontag which was included in cupcakes and kalashnikovs. The essay discussed the recentlyreleased photographs of torture at abu ghraib prison in iraq, the bush administrations response, and the power of photography to. In regarding the pain of others, susan sontag takes a fresh look at the representation of atrocityfrom goyas the disasters of war to photographs of the american civil war, lynchings of blacks in the south, and the nazi death camps, to contemporary horrific images of bosnia epub, sierra leone, rwanda, israel and palestine, and new york city. Worth seeking out is a shorter piece sontag wrote called regarding the torture of others quite true to its title after the abu ghirab prison photographs were released. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of regarding the pain of others by susan sontag. Regarding the pain of others kindle edition by sontag. So i havent wanted to see the pictures any more than i have wanted to see a video of the beheading. Regarding the pain of others originally appeared in the new yorker under a different title, looking at war.
Buy a cheap copy of regarding the pain of others book by susan sontag. When sontag s article came out, ed to see how she applied her method of inquiry and analysis to the news of american soldiers torturing whomever detainees, prisoners of war, wtfever it is they have in those iraqi prisons. Regarding the torture of others susan sontag new york times. Oct 17, 2012 a summary of regarding the torture of others by. The first edition of the novel was published in january 7th 2001, and was written by susan sontag. Pdf regarding the pain of others book by susan sontag free. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading regarding the pain of others. From goyas disasters of war to news footage and photographs of the conflicts in vietnam, rwanda and bosnia, pictures have been charged with inspiring dissent, fostering violence or instilling apathy in us, the viewer. Dec 12, 2016 regarding the torture of others by susan sontag susan sontag born january 16, 1933 december 28, 2004 was an american writer, filmmaker, teacher, and political activist.
For a long time at least six decades photographs have laid down the tracks of how important conflicts are judged and remembered. Sontag regarding the pain of others free pdf file sharing. The sequelofsorts to on photography 1977, sontag revisits some of the same issues she raised in her earlier book, and subjects them to renewed, closer scrutiny. Feb 20, 2015 a quick summary of regarding the torture of others by susan sontag which was included in cupcakes and kalashnikovs. Regarding the pain of others download pdfepub ebook. Photographs have an insuperable power to determine what we recall of events, and it now. Susan sontag is the author of four novels, the benefactor, death kit, the volcano lover, and in america, which won the 2000 national book award for fiction. Susan sontag s now classic book on photography defined the terms of this debate twentyfive years ago. Susan sontag 19332004 was the author of four novels, the benefactor, death kit, the volcano lover, and in america, which won the 2000 national book award for fiction. Pdf regarding the pain of others in susan sontag and. The essay discussed the recentlyreleased photographs of torture at abu ghraib prison in iraq, the bush administrations response, and the power of photography to shape ideas and. Sontag is clear about disbelieving in collective memory and states that it is the artifacts, photographs, we are left with that determine our feelings.
798 14 503 582 1514 629 962 598 932 842 95 1535 778 1302 858 104 1249 955 1409 1467 338 625 85 1651 272 1251 795 1219 769 1266 1448 544 242 401 1179 579 468